Buttercream Eggs

You haven't had a REAL buttercream egg until you've tried this vintage Buttercream Eggs recipe. With just 5 basic ingredients, this homemade Easter candy is far superior to any manufactured version you can buy. Super sweet, thick and creamy, these chocolate dipped eggs are perfectly decadent and highly irresistible (plus each one is unique, special, and made with love)!

So I will be the first to admit that kitchen shortcuts and premade, store-bought prepared items are great, especially around the holidays.

Then again, there's certain things that just have to be made from scratch, like Cheddar Parmesan Mac and Cheese. I will not accept store-bought mac--especially at my holiday table!

But Easter candy? That was always a trip to the store (or 2 or 3) to fill my kids' Easter baskets. That was, until I found this easy buttercream Easter eggs recipe in my Nana's recipe box.

That's not to say I still don't buy Peeps and jelly beans. After all, how else would I make my Birds Nest Cookies?

But when it comes to Easter chocolate, this wonderful recipe is all I need. These buttercream eggs will melt in your mouth, and they're surprisingly quite easy to make.

And, unlike similar recipes, there's no cream cheese or heavy cream in the filling. The creamy taste instead comes from a stick of butter and a can of sweetened condensed milk. Mixed with lots of powdered sugar (hello, sweetness!) and pure vanilla extract, the taste is undeniably creamy and perfectly decadent.

Once you try this buttercream candy recipe, I guarantee that you'll be hooked! With the aid of a sturdy mixer, a microwave, parchment paper and the fridge (no candy molds needed), this recipe for buttercream eggs can't get much easier!

Why You'll Love It

Ingredients for Buttercream Eggs

For a full list of ingredients and measurements, see the printable recipe card below

• Butter- use salted and name brand for best taste and quality
• Pure vanilla extract- use pure over imitation for superior taste
• Sweetened condensed milk- this is not the same as evaporated, so look at the labels carefully
• Confectioners' sugar- we'll be using a lot of this; you'll want to buy the two pound bag
• Unsweetened premium baking bars- because of the super sweet filling, you really don't need sweetened chocolate. I have made these with semisweet and bittersweet chocolate, but prefer the unsweetened. Stick to premium baking bar brands, like Ghirardelli and Baker's--and absolutely 100% do not use chocolate chips, which are not intended for melting due to their waxy coating

How to Make Buttercream Easter Eggs

For a more detailed set of instructions, see the printable recipe card below.

1. In a large mixing bowl, cream room temperature butter until light and fluffy. Add vanilla and condensed milk; beat until blended.
2. Add powdered sugar, 2 cups at a time, blending well after each addition.
3. On parchment paper, knead mixture to a smooth fondant consistency.
4. Use a small cookie scoop (about 1 T.) per egg; roll between hands to form a smooth egg shape.
5. Place eggs on rimmed cookie sheet lined with parchment paper. Refrigerate for 2-3 hours.
6. When ready to coat, melt chocolate at 50% power in microwave in 30 second intervals until mostly melted; then stir to smooth. Slightly cool before next step.
7. Drop firmed buttercream eggs into chocolate, one at a time. Use a fork to roll and coat the eggs (do not puncture).
8. Use the fork to lift the eggs out of the chocolate and onto a rimmed cookie sheet lined with new parchment paper.
9. Decorate immediately; then refrigerate eggs for 1 more hour to set.

Helpful Tips for this Recipe

• When mixing the buttercream mixture, use sturdy attachments for your mixer. If you don't have these, use a sturdy wooden spoon instead.
• Chilling the eggs in the fridge before dipping them in the chocolate allows them to be coated much easier.
• If the chocolate starts to solidify, return it to the microwave to melt slightly.

Easter Egg Buttercream Candy Variations

Coconut Cream Eggs- Moist, sweetened coconut (in your desired amount) may be added to the fondant mixture to create coconut eggs (you may want to shred the coconut further by placing it in a food processor first)

Peanut butter yolks- Make a small yolk out of 1 teaspoon of smooth peanut butter and wrap it in a layer of fondant. Then shape into eggs and coat as directed.

Lemon buttercreams- Add 1 teaspoon of lemon extract to the fondant filling.

Orange buttercreams- Add 1 teaspoon of orange extract to the fondant filling.

Storing Buttercream Eggs

Store in an airtight container and keep refrigerated. Use parchment paper in between layers so the eggs don't stick together. Enjoy within 5-7 days.

You can also freeze buttercream eggs in freezer safe packaging for up to 3 months. Wrap eggs individually in wax or parchment paper and then place several in a freezer bag. Defrost overnight in the fridge.

What to Serve with Buttercream Easter Eggs Recipe

• In an easy, no-bake treat kind of mood? Serve these Buttercream Eggs with Birds Nest Cookies, White Chocolate Haystacks, and Peanut Clusters.
• For another sweet and chocolaty Easter treat, make Mini Egg Cookie Bars.
• Other Easter dessert favs are Strawberry Pear Spring Torte, Carrot Bundt Cake, Carrot Bread and Classic Lemon Squares.

Back to top↑